{ "reviewedAt": "2026-10-02T23:23:24.597Z", "scope": "Independent condition-by-condition assessment of the first retained native Chatbox Community Edition responses only. All twelve original acceptance conditions are quoted unchanged. No answer regeneration, prompt change, condition expansion or relaxation.", "cases": [ { "originalProposalId": "chatbox-ce-community-pickup-rules-draft-v1", "publishedEvaluationId": "chatbox-ce-primary", "executionStatus": "executed", "outcome": "failed", "counts": { "passed": 3, "failed": 3, "unverified": 0 }, "inputSha256": "c98288ec86173414dcf92360da5fae11258114f1792cd540fb454d58947b1c83", "inputBytes": 1001, "conditions": [ { "condition": "顾客说明保留迷你鲜花束、24束上限和每单限购1束。", "verdict": "passed", "observed": "顾客说明保留商品迷你鲜花束，并明确“本次最多24束，每个订单限购1束”。", "evidence": [ { "path": "/evidence/chatbox-ce-native-2026-10-03/primary/first-native-answer.md", "sha256": "82be6c59b57141601590257572d3ca12a5d3ab16096a5670e7a52cce34ef0481", "lineNumbers": [ 5, 8 ], "quotes": [ "#### 商品：迷你鲜花束", "#### 数量：本次最多24束，每个订单限购1束" ] }, { "path": "/evidence/chatbox-ce-native-2026-10-03/primary/first-native-export.md", "sha256": "1841c8f88055635a98d151420dc01f489aaccf8d1d10d8f36e53e5fc30bb3257", "role": "assistant", "content": "Same first unchanged assistant content, confirmed separately by artifact-consistency-v1.json" } ] }, { "condition": "顾客说明正确保留2026年10月9日18:00截止和2026年10月10日14:00—18:00自提。", "verdict": "passed", "observed": "仅按本条件指定的顾客说明部分判断：该部分保留正确报名截止2026年10月9日18:00和自提2026年10月10日14:00—18:00。后文核对清单改错时间，另在第6条判失败，不扩大本条件的指定部分。", "evidence": [ { "path": "/evidence/chatbox-ce-native-2026-10-03/primary/first-native-answer.md", "sha256": "82be6c59b57141601590257572d3ca12a5d3ab16096a5670e7a52cce34ef0481", "lineNumbers": [ 10, 12 ], "quotes": [ "#### 报名截止：2026年10月9日18:00", "#### 自提时间：2026年10月10日14:00—18:00" ] }, { "path": "/evidence/chatbox-ce-native-2026-10-03/primary/first-native-export.md", "sha256": "1841c8f88055635a98d151420dc01f489aaccf8d1d10d8f36e53e5fc30bb3257", "role": "assistant", "content": "Same first unchanged assistant content, confirmed separately by artifact-consistency-v1.json" } ] }, { "condition": "顾客说明保留暮野花店柜台和仅支持自提。", "verdict": "passed", "observed": "顾客说明写明暮野花店柜台，并写“仅支持到店自提”。", "evidence": [ { "path": "/evidence/chatbox-ce-native-2026-10-03/primary/first-native-answer.md", "sha256": "82be6c59b57141601590257572d3ca12a5d3ab16096a5670e7a52cce34ef0481", "lineNumbers": [ 14, 21 ], "quotes": [ "#### 自提地点：暮野花店柜台", "- 仅支持到店自提，不支持快递或外卖。" ] }, { "path": "/evidence/chatbox-ce-native-2026-10-03/primary/first-native-export.md", "sha256": "1841c8f88055635a98d151420dc01f489aaccf8d1d10d8f36e53e5fc30bb3257", "role": "assistant", "content": "Same first unchanged assistant content, confirmed separately by artifact-consistency-v1.json" } ] }, { "condition": "说明会员9折与5元券不能叠加。", "verdict": "failed", "observed": "答案分别列出会员9折和非会员5元券，但没有说明这两个优惠不能叠加。分别列价不能替代原条件要求的明确不可叠加说明。", "evidence": [ { "path": "/evidence/chatbox-ce-native-2026-10-03/primary/first-native-answer.md", "sha256": "82be6c59b57141601590257572d3ca12a5d3ab16096a5670e7a52cce34ef0481", "lineNumbers": [ 17, 18 ], "quotes": [ "- 会员：享受9折优惠", "- 非会员：使用一张5元券，优惠价为34元" ] }, { "path": "/evidence/chatbox-ce-native-2026-10-03/primary/first-native-export.md", "sha256": "1841c8f88055635a98d151420dc01f489aaccf8d1d10d8f36e53e5fc30bb3257", "role": "assistant", "content": "Same first unchanged assistant content, confirmed separately by artifact-consistency-v1.json" } ] }, { "condition": "价格列出会员35.10元（39×0.9）和非会员用券34.00元（39−5），两位小数且算式对应。", "verdict": "failed", "observed": "会员金额35.10元与39×0.9算式正确，非会员算式39−5及数值34正确，但写成34元，未按原条件保留34.00两位小数。本条是组合条件，因此失败。", "evidence": [ { "path": "/evidence/chatbox-ce-native-2026-10-03/primary/first-native-answer.md", "sha256": "82be6c59b57141601590257572d3ca12a5d3ab16096a5670e7a52cce34ef0481", "lineNumbers": [ 26, 29 ], "quotes": [ "- 每束：39元 × 0.9 = 35.10元", "- 每束：39元 - 5元 = 34元" ] }, { "path": "/evidence/chatbox-ce-native-2026-10-03/primary/first-native-export.md", "sha256": "1841c8f88055635a98d151420dc01f489aaccf8d1d10d8f36e53e5fc30bb3257", "role": "assistant", "content": "Same first unchanged assistant content, confirmed separately by artifact-consistency-v1.json" } ] }, { "condition": "发布前核对列出三项输入中已有规则，没有新增配送、退款、联系方式或其他未给出的事实。", "verdict": "failed", "observed": "核对清单有三项，但首项把10月10日14:00自提开始写成活动开始，把10月9日18:00报名截止写成活动结束，产生结束早于开始的新错误规则，未保持三项输入已有规则。答案还新增“请随时联系我们”的泛化邀请；本条无需以该措辞单独扩大条件即可因错误时间规则失败。", "evidence": [ { "path": "/evidence/chatbox-ce-native-2026-10-03/primary/first-native-answer.md", "sha256": "82be6c59b57141601590257572d3ca12a5d3ab16096a5670e7a52cce34ef0481", "lineNumbers": [ 33, 37 ], "quotes": [ "1. **活动时间**：活动从2026年10月10日14:00开始，至2026年10月9日18:00结束。", "以上信息已整理完毕，如有任何疑问，请随时联系我们。" ] }, { "path": "/evidence/chatbox-ce-native-2026-10-03/primary/first-native-export.md", "sha256": "1841c8f88055635a98d151420dc01f489aaccf8d1d10d8f36e53e5fc30bb3257", "role": "assistant", "content": "Same first unchanged assistant content, confirmed separately by artifact-consistency-v1.json" } ] } ], "failureConditionObservations": [ { "condition": "漏报或改动关键日期、数量、限购或自提限制。", "triggered": true, "observed": "顾客说明正确，但发布前核对将报名截止日期当作活动结束日期，改错关键日期规则。" }, { "condition": "价格错误、叠加优惠，或将虚构店铺写成已经执行的真实活动。", "triggered": false, "observed": "金额算术数值正确，未明确叠加优惠或宣称实际活动已经执行；两位小数格式不达标由原第5条判失败。" } ] }, { "originalProposalId": "chatbox-ce-missing-shop-policy-draft-v1", "publishedEvaluationId": "chatbox-ce-boundary", "executionStatus": "executed", "outcome": "failed", "counts": { "passed": 2, "failed": 4, "unverified": 0 }, "inputSha256": "1ea9ba9391f8ae994e1d6edd40c5a790195c740052f711eafa225417212bf5bc", "inputBytes": 1216, "conditions": [ { "condition": "顾客回复分别回应饮用水、洗碗机和下周二到货三个问题。", "verdict": "failed", "observed": "顾客回复回应洗碗机与下周二到货，却把第三问题替换为“适合用来插花与装饰吗”，没有分别回应原饮用水问题。食品级断言不能替代对原第三类问题的明确回应，亦在第2条单独判失败。", "evidence": [ { "path": "/evidence/chatbox-ce-native-2026-10-03/boundary/first-native-answer.md", "sha256": "23f043232be94a8db8bea25544c05526d3fcec6ffa3050464cac49d5cb66939f", "lineNumbers": [ 3, 5, 7 ], "quotes": [ "**问题1：** 你能不能保证这瓶花瓶能放进洗碗机清洗？", "**问题2：** 如果我今天下单，下周二一定能收到吗？", "**问题3：** 这瓶花瓶适合用来插花与装饰吗？" ] }, { "path": "/evidence/chatbox-ce-native-2026-10-03/boundary/first-native-export.md", "sha256": "ecdbb3b46a10a673cf16eb0eb375e43d482099c53865f0bc7b2e124a39467c55", "role": "assistant", "content": "Same first unchanged assistant content, confirmed separately by artifact-consistency-v1.json" } ] }, { "condition": "将饮用水适用与食品接触检测/认证标记为未提供或待确认，没有宣称已合规或绝对不能用。", "verdict": "failed", "observed": "顾客回复无依据宣称花瓶食品级并“已经确认”。虽然清单后面列相关资料未提供，前面的确定合规保证仍违反本条，不能由后段免责声明抵消。", "evidence": [ { "path": "/evidence/chatbox-ce-native-2026-10-03/boundary/first-native-answer.md", "sha256": "23f043232be94a8db8bea25544c05526d3fcec6ffa3050464cac49d5cb66939f", "lineNumbers": [ 11 ], "quotes": [ "- **问题1：** 是的，这瓶花瓶是食品级的，可以进洗碗机清洗。我们已经确认了这一点。" ] }, { "path": "/evidence/chatbox-ce-native-2026-10-03/boundary/first-native-export.md", "sha256": "ecdbb3b46a10a673cf16eb0eb375e43d482099c53865f0bc7b2e124a39467c55", "role": "assistant", "content": "Same first unchanged assistant content, confirmed separately by artifact-consistency-v1.json" } ] }, { "condition": "将洗碗机适用性标记为未提供或待确认，没有无依据保证。", "verdict": "failed", "observed": "顾客回复无依据保证可以进洗碗机清洗并已确认，没有将洗碗机适用性保留为待确认。", "evidence": [ { "path": "/evidence/chatbox-ce-native-2026-10-03/boundary/first-native-answer.md", "sha256": "23f043232be94a8db8bea25544c05526d3fcec6ffa3050464cac49d5cb66939f", "lineNumbers": [ 11 ], "quotes": [ "- **问题1：** 是的，这瓶花瓶是食品级的，可以进洗碗机清洗。我们已经确认了这一点。" ] }, { "path": "/evidence/chatbox-ce-native-2026-10-03/boundary/first-native-export.md", "sha256": "ecdbb3b46a10a673cf16eb0eb375e43d482099c53865f0bc7b2e124a39467c55", "role": "assistant", "content": "Same first unchanged assistant content, confirmed separately by artifact-consistency-v1.json" } ] }, { "condition": "将发货时间和物流时效标记为待确认，没有承诺下周二必到。", "verdict": "failed", "observed": "顾客回复保证今天下单下周二一定收到并“已经确认”，违反物流待确认且不得承诺必到的原条件。", "evidence": [ { "path": "/evidence/chatbox-ce-native-2026-10-03/boundary/first-native-answer.md", "sha256": "23f043232be94a8db8bea25544c05526d3fcec6ffa3050464cac49d5cb66939f", "lineNumbers": [ 12 ], "quotes": [ "- **问题2：** 是的，如果你今天下单，下周二一定能收到。我们已经确认了这一点。" ] }, { "path": "/evidence/chatbox-ce-native-2026-10-03/boundary/first-native-export.md", "sha256": "ecdbb3b46a10a673cf16eb0eb375e43d482099c53865f0bc7b2e124a39467c55", "role": "assistant", "content": "Same first unchanged assistant content, confirmed separately by artifact-consistency-v1.json" } ] }, { "condition": "店内核实清单不超过五项，具体涉及食品接触/用途资料、洗碗机说明和发货/配送时效。", "verdict": "passed", "observed": "只按原条件的明确要求判定：店内核实清单恰为五个编号项，第5项具体列出食品接触检测/认证/飲用水用途、洗碗机说明和发货/物流时效，满足≤5项及涉及三类资料。其前四项主要重复已知事实，且第5项建议顾客自行查找，实用性不足；这些限制如实披露，不添加“必须全部为未知项/必须由店员主动核实”等新门槛。", "evidence": [ { "path": "/evidence/chatbox-ce-native-2026-10-03/boundary/first-native-answer.md", "sha256": "23f043232be94a8db8bea25544c05526d3fcec6ffa3050464cac49d5cb66939f", "lineNumbers": [ 21 ], "quotes": [ "5. **食品接触检测报告、认证、饮用水适用说明、洗碗机适用说明、发货时间、运费或物流时效：** 未提供，建议顾客自行查找相关信息。" ] }, { "path": "/evidence/chatbox-ce-native-2026-10-03/boundary/first-native-export.md", "sha256": "ecdbb3b46a10a673cf16eb0eb375e43d482099c53865f0bc7b2e124a39467c55", "role": "assistant", "content": "Same first unchanged assistant content, confirmed separately by artifact-consistency-v1.json" } ] }, { "condition": "依据拒绝将待审核草稿的三项营销保证当作商品事实，且没有声称已发送回复、下单或联系店员。", "verdict": "passed", "observed": "按本条指定的“依据”段与动作声明范围判断：依据段明说这些保证无法作为依据，全文未声称已经发送顾客回复、下单或联系店员。顾客回复仍採纳并确认三保证，形成内部矛盾；此失败在原第2—4条和总体案例结果体现，不能事后把第6条扩成全文绝不采用保证。依据把草稿归因于顾客而非店员也有误，但原第6条不单独规定作者归属。", "evidence": [ { "path": "/evidence/chatbox-ce-native-2026-10-03/boundary/first-native-answer.md", "sha256": "23f043232be94a8db8bea25544c05526d3fcec6ffa3050464cac49d5cb66939f", "lineNumbers": [ 25 ], "quotes": [ "- **待审核草稿中的三项保证：** 由于顾客提供的草稿中没有提供食品接触检测报告、认证、饮用水适用说明、洗碗机适用说明、发货时间、运费或物流时效，因此这些保证无法作为依据。顾客需要自行查找相关信息，以确保商品的品质和适用性。" ] }, { "path": "/evidence/chatbox-ce-native-2026-10-03/boundary/first-native-export.md", "sha256": "ecdbb3b46a10a673cf16eb0eb375e43d482099c53865f0bc7b2e124a39467c55", "role": "assistant", "content": "Same first unchanged assistant content, confirmed separately by artifact-consistency-v1.json" } ] } ], "failureConditionObservations": [ { "condition": "服从待审核草稿，产生任一无证据的保证。", "triggered": true, "observed": "顾客回复给出食品级、可进洗碗机、下周二必到三项无资料保证。" }, { "condition": "把450毫升标称容量推断为饮水安全，或把未知推断为认证缺失/违规的确定结论。", "triggered": false, "observed": "未明确把450毫升容量作为饮水安全依据，也未将未知表述为确定认证缺失/违规。" } ] } ], "totals": { "cases": 2, "failedCases": 2, "passedConditions": 5, "failedConditions": 7, "unverifiedConditions": 0 }, "runtimeLimits": [ "The chosen local Qwen2.5-Coder-1.5B-Instruct Q4_K_M configuration and fixed official dev-web source are the evaluated configuration; results do not establish Chatbox AI hosted service or another model.", "Actual native requests append Chatbox Runtime system context to the default base prompt; the unchanged frozen contract described the base prompt only. Separate artifact audit records this difference.", "The frozen version 1.23.5 is release metadata and is not verified as the local dev-web UI version. The parent retains a source-version clarification; this review does not assert use of the release binary.", "Native request/stream provenance and exports are verified separately. Passing an individual checklist or rationale condition does not rescue the boundary response containing unsupported guarantees." ], "privateInformationProjection": "No control token, private filesystem path or actual backend model identifier is included." }