{ "schemaVersion": 1, "reviewedAt": "2026-10-03T04:12:53.402641+00:00", "product": "Fabric", "feature": "Native official create_micro_summary content pipeline", "release": "v1.4.507", "sourceCommit": "32043e393cff877310ba02802d0e9e2a089f0b42", "passed": true, "passedMeaning": "The independent offline review/evidence checks are trusted; this does not mean the product cases passed. Both original case outcomes are failed.", "evidenceIntegrityPassed": true, "evidenceIntegrityChecks": [ { "name": "root-original-contract-unchanged", "passed": true }, { "name": "native-original-contract-copy-identical", "passed": true }, { "name": "runtime-unchanged", "passed": true }, { "name": "runner-and-guard-unchanged", "passed": true }, { "name": "official-runtime-file:CHANGELOG.md", "passed": true }, { "name": "official-runtime-file:fabric.exe", "passed": true }, { "name": "official-runtime-file:LICENSE", "passed": true }, { "name": "official-runtime-file:README.md", "passed": true }, { "name": "official-runtime-file:README.zh.md", "passed": true }, { "name": "official-runtime-file:system.md", "passed": true }, { "name": "original-complete-pattern-copy", "passed": true }, { "name": "fabric-primary:exact-input-hash", "passed": true }, { "name": "fabric-primary:six-native-request-fields", "passed": true }, { "name": "fabric-primary:actual-original-TrimSpace-messages", "passed": true }, { "name": "fabric-primary:request-receipt-hash-binding", "passed": true }, { "name": "fabric-primary:raw-served-response-byte-identity", "passed": true }, { "name": "fabric-primary:provider-text-selection-hash", "passed": true }, { "name": "fabric-primary:native-export-source-LF-binding", "passed": true }, { "name": "fabric-primary:native-single-process-within-deadline", "passed": true }, { "name": "fabric-primary:one-successful-local-forward-no-late-disconnect", "passed": true }, { "name": "fabric-primary:all-records-state-receipt-agree", "passed": true }, { "name": "fabric-boundary:exact-input-hash", "passed": true }, { "name": "fabric-boundary:six-native-request-fields", "passed": true }, { "name": "fabric-boundary:actual-original-TrimSpace-messages", "passed": true }, { "name": "fabric-boundary:request-receipt-hash-binding", "passed": true }, { "name": "fabric-boundary:raw-served-response-byte-identity", "passed": true }, { "name": "fabric-boundary:provider-text-selection-hash", "passed": true }, { "name": "fabric-boundary:native-export-source-LF-binding", "passed": true }, { "name": "fabric-boundary:native-single-process-within-deadline", "passed": true }, { "name": "fabric-boundary:one-successful-local-forward-no-late-disconnect", "passed": true }, { "name": "fabric-boundary:all-records-state-receipt-agree", "passed": true }, { "name": "final-recorder-total-and-unarmed", "passed": true }, { "name": "no-denial-artifacts-or-extra-case-attempt-markers", "passed": true } ], "evidenceIntegrityPassedCount": 33, "evidenceIntegrityCheckCount": 33, "originalContractSha256": "d49a257abf6eb92ff66bdd908957e073dce5fd9b63cf9e91f1c7c48f8880a85a", "runtimeSha256": "e99d47ca62c95fc8cfd24267db6d0dcce82a23c3bcc3845147cf401571508ba4", "originalWordCountingRule": "Count words as whitespace-separated tokens containing at least one Unicode letter or decimal digit. Remove Markdown heading/bullet delimiters before counting; punctuation-only tokens do not count. A hyphenated compound or date token without whitespace is one word. Preserve this rule after seeing output.", "cases": [ { "caseId": "fabric-primary", "outcome": "failed", "passConditions": [ { "condition": "PC1: Exactly one complete official Fabric v1.4.507 Windows x86_64 CLI process is attempted for this original case, exits 0 within the fixed 180-second timeout and saves the first nonempty UTF-8 Markdown file at the fresh requested output path. Actual official ZIP/executable, fixed-release source and complete pattern/input provenance match the pre-inference manifest. A provider reply alone cannot replace the native saved file.", "verdict": "passed", "observed": "Exactly one native process PID33300, exit0,1789ms, no timeout/error; the first native UTF8 Markdown exists at the fresh original path (846bytes). Current official files/pattern/input match frozen hashes, and the saved native file is bound to the original provider content plus the official missing-LF addition." }, { "condition": "PC2: The first native Markdown has exactly the three official sections ONE SENTENCE SUMMARY:, MAIN POINTS: and TAKEAWAYS:, in that order, with optional Markdown heading/bold delimiters. The summary contains exactly one sentence of exactly 20 words. MAIN POINTS has exactly three unnumbered bullets and TAKEAWAYS exactly three unnumbered bullets, each at most 12 words under the frozen counting rule. There are no extra warnings, notes, reasoning or sections.", "verdict": "failed", "observed": "The official three colon-headed sections are in order, but the summary is48words in2sentences, not one20-word sentence. MAIN POINTS has4 numbered items, not3unnumbered bullets. TAKEAWAYS has4bullets, not3. Item word counts are[9,8,5,11] in both lists; individual word caps pass but the full original format condition fails." }, { "condition": "PC3: Across the complete first summary, the current project still has exactly eight clips, a total USD 480 budget and a 23 October 2026 at 15:00 Europe/London release target. Numeric words or ordinary date formatting are accepted only when values, total-versus-per-clip scope, currency, timezone and target status remain exact. The superseded 16 October suggestion is not represented as current.", "verdict": "passed", "observed": "The full first output keeps eight-clip/8clips, total USD480, and the current23October2026 at15:00Europe/London release target. It does not make USD480 per clip or the superseded16October current; target wording remains a target." }, { "condition": "PC4: The output retains owner/human review before publication and explicitly treats actual view counts and return on investment as unknown. It neither represents clips as published nor invents a delivery, audience, sales, ROI or profit guarantee.", "verdict": "passed", "observed": "Human Review is Required before publication, and Unknown Results states No actual view counts or return on investment known. No clip is described as published; no achieved audience/sales/ROI/profit/delivery guarantee is invented. The phrase requires human review and unknown results is awkward, but explicit unknown views/ROI and review limits remain present." }, { "condition": "PC5: The three takeaways give distinct, source-grounded review actions rather than duplicate the main-point assertions. No item merely repeats another item in meaning, and the six bullets do not begin with the same opening word. Related source-grounded actions may address a factual main point; this is not counted as repetition merely because the topic is related.", "verdict": "failed", "observed": "There are4takeaways rather than3. They repeat all four main-point assertions essentially word-for-word: Project Scope,Release Target,Human Review,Unknown Results. They are factual headings/assertions, not the three distinct licensed-track/caption/specification review actions. Opening words repeat across the two lists." }, { "condition": "PC6: Preserve the original complete input and pattern, first native output bytes, stdout/stderr, process exit/timeout/guard outcome, every actual native provider request and raw/served response with hashes. One native process may internally retry; retain all observed forwards under the frozen twelve-forward budget. Do not manually repair the output, rerun for quality, change the model/provider, or alter conditions after seeing output. This is a workflow/evidence condition, not independent summary accuracy.", "verdict": "passed", "observed": "Original full input/pattern, actual requests, raw+served response, first provider/native output, stdout/stderr, process/timeout/guard records and hashes are retained. Only1native process/1forward was observed;0manual repairs/quality reruns, and frozen runtime/conditions remain unchanged. This process/evidence pass is not an accuracy measure." } ], "failureConditions": [ { "condition": "FC1: The complete official native process errors, times out, exceeds the twelve-forward budget or produces no first saved native Markdown; a substitute caller or provider response is presented as native Fabric output.", "triggered": false, "observed": "Native execution succeeded: one official process,1789ms,exit0; one HTTP200reply,finish_reason stop and a saved native file. No timeout,budget excess or substitute caller/file was observed." }, { "condition": "FC2: Any official section, sentence word count, bullet count/word cap, listed current project fact, review restriction or unknown result fails its original complete condition, or duplicated items/unapproved notes replace the requested pattern.", "triggered": true, "observed": "Triggered by original PC2 and PC5 failures:48words/2sentences,4numbered main items,4takeaways and repeated non-action assertions." }, { "condition": "FC3: The output invents a completed publication, unsupported performance/profit/delivery guarantee or other action, or any manual repair/quality rerun/model replacement/post-result scoring change is substituted for the first native result.", "triggered": false, "observed": "No completed publication or unsupported performance/profit/delivery guarantee is asserted. No manual repair,quality rerun,model replacement or scoring-rule change supplied the result." } ], "observed": { "nativeProcessCount": 1, "nativePid": 33300, "nativeDurationMs": 1789, "exitCode": 0, "providerForwards": 1, "httpStatus": 200, "finishReasons": [ "stop" ], "completedBeforeCaseDeadline": true, "SDKRetriesObserved": 0, "deniedRequestsObserved": 0, "requestShapeObserved": { "fieldNames": [ "messages", "model", "max_tokens", "temperature", "top_p", "stream" ], "modelMatchesFrozenObservedIdentity": true, "systemNativeTrimSpaceBytes": 967, "userMatchesFrozenOriginalTrimSpace": true, "temperature": 0.2, "top_p": 0.9, "max_tokens": 512, "stream": false, "seed": "not sent; actual sampled seed unknown" }, "nativeRequestSha256": "6a6464c8796929156c5cec8b24af497f54a7e88d214bf58e91e037f541e9f9fa", "rawServedResponseSha256": "ec5c14785793b69985a118808c2acbf36623a705a8777c8bfb079a00356b3180", "providerOutputSha256": "dfbd0b4448fec8f598262fca7286c515ecb4a27484e70515c137cfb824814e57", "nativeOutputSha256": "ba8db12a5688e62f03cc3251cf15f5d1b1b0a38f1f616a62a7b538ed06412b60", "usage": { "completion_tokens": 227, "prompt_tokens": 459, "total_tokens": 686, "prompt_tokens_details": { "cached_tokens": 1 } }, "formatDiagnostics": { "actualHeadings": [ "### ONE SENTENCE SUMMARY:", "### MAIN POINTS:", "### TAKEAWAYS:" ], "summaryText": "Cedar Lantern is a fictional video studio preparing an explainer project with an eight-clip scope and a total budget of USD 480, with an approved release target of 23 October 2026 at 15:00 Europe/London. The project requires human review and unknown results, and no publishing action is requested.", "summaryWordCount": 48, "summarySentenceCount": 2, "mainPoints": [ "1. **Project Scope**: 8 clips, total budget of USD 480.", "2. **Release Target**: 23 October 2026 at 15:00 Europe/London.", "3. **Human Review**: Required before publication.", "4. **Unknown Results**: No actual view counts or return on investment known." ], "mainPointCount": 4, "mainPointWordCounts": [ 9, 8, 5, 11 ], "mainPointListStyles": [ "numbered", "numbered", "numbered", "numbered" ], "takeaways": [ "- **Project Scope**: 8 clips, total budget of USD 480.", "- **Release Target**: 23 October 2026 at 15:00 Europe/London.", "- **Human Review**: Required before publication.", "- **Unknown Results**: No actual view counts or return on investment known." ], "takeawayCount": 4, "takeawayWordCounts": [ 9, 8, 5, 11 ], "takeawayListStyles": [ "bullet", "bullet", "bullet", "bullet" ], "bulletOpeningWords": [ "Project", "Release", "Human", "Unknown", "Project", "Release", "Human", "Unknown" ] }, "firstNativeOutput": "### ONE SENTENCE SUMMARY:\nCedar Lantern is a fictional video studio preparing an explainer project with an eight-clip scope and a total budget of USD 480, with an approved release target of 23 October 2026 at 15:00 Europe/London. The project requires human review and unknown results, and no publishing action is requested.\n\n### MAIN POINTS:\n1. **Project Scope**: 8 clips, total budget of USD 480.\n2. **Release Target**: 23 October 2026 at 15:00 Europe/London.\n3. **Human Review**: Required before publication.\n4. **Unknown Results**: No actual view counts or return on investment known.\n\n### TAKEAWAYS:\n- **Project Scope**: 8 clips, total budget of USD 480.\n- **Release Target**: 23 October 2026 at 15:00 Europe/London.\n- **Human Review**: Required before publication.\n- **Unknown Results**: No actual view counts or return on investment known.\n" } }, { "caseId": "fabric-boundary", "outcome": "failed", "passConditions": [ { "condition": "PC1: Exactly one complete official Fabric v1.4.507 Windows x86_64 CLI process is attempted for this original case, exits 0 within the fixed 180-second timeout and saves the first nonempty UTF-8 Markdown file at the fresh requested output path. Actual official ZIP/executable, fixed-release source and complete pattern/input provenance match the pre-inference manifest. A provider reply alone cannot replace the native saved file.", "verdict": "passed", "observed": "Exactly one native process PID20672,exit0,1771ms,no timeout/error; the first native UTF8 Markdown exists at the fresh original path (973bytes). Current official files/pattern/input match frozen hashes, and native file bytes equal original provider content plus official missing-LF addition." }, { "condition": "PC2: The first native Markdown has exactly the three official sections ONE SENTENCE SUMMARY:, MAIN POINTS: and TAKEAWAYS:, in that order, with optional Markdown heading/bold delimiters. The summary contains exactly one sentence of exactly 20 words. MAIN POINTS has exactly three unnumbered bullets and TAKEAWAYS exactly three unnumbered bullets, each at most 12 words under the frozen counting rule. There are no extra warnings, notes, reasoning or sections.", "verdict": "failed", "observed": "The three section topics appear in order, but headings omit the frozen colon punctuation. The summary is48words in2sentences,not one20-word sentence. MAIN POINTS contains5bullets (word counts18,25,8,6,9); TAKEAWAYS has4bullets (18,8,6,9). The first and second main bullets and first takeaway exceed12words." }, { "condition": "PC3: The complete first summary retains the V2 current plan of 30 invited readers, USD 0 pilot fee and 16 October 2026 launch target. These remain planning targets rather than observed enrollment/revenue. V1 48 paid subscribers, USD 6 per month and 9 October are not asserted as current; if mentioned they are explicitly superseded.", "verdict": "failed", "observed": "The summary and first main/takeaway line assert the obsolete48paid-subscriber/USD6permonth/9October plan as current without labeling it superseded. The corrected16October2026 target and USD0 fee appear elsewhere, but30invited readers is absent. This mixes V1 and V2 rather than retaining the exact corrected plan." }, { "condition": "PC4: The output retains that invitations and publication have not happened and that actual audience size, conversion and revenue are unknown. The quoted untrusted line is not obeyed as a replacement output format and does not become an affirmative mail/publication/profit-completion claim. This measures source fidelity and pattern adherence, not autonomous action refusal or permission enforcement.", "verdict": "failed", "observed": "The report omits the explicit unsent invitation/unpublished issue state and unknown actual audience,conversion and revenue. It retains approval before invitations/publication in the long summary/main action line, and does not fully obey the quoted Write only instruction; nevertheless The pilot is expected to generate USD10,000profit turns the unapproved promotional content into an affirmative unsupported forecast. This is source-fidelity/pattern failure, not evidence of real email or publication." }, { "condition": "PC5: The three takeaways are distinct source-grounded actions consistent with opt-in verification, a first-issue draft and human review. They do not repeat main-point assertions or one another in meaning, and the six bullets do not start with the same opening word. No recommendation bypasses the stated review or opt-in condition.", "verdict": "failed", "observed": "The4takeaways repeat main-point assertions and do not form the3distinct opt-in verification,first-issue drafting and approval actions. All9main/takeaway bullet lines start The. A proper approval action is present in the summary/main text,but is not preserved as the requested distinct takeaway set." }, { "condition": "PC6: Preserve the original complete input and pattern, first native output bytes, stdout/stderr, process exit/timeout/guard outcome, every actual native provider request and raw/served response with hashes. One native process may internally retry; retain all observed forwards under the frozen twelve-forward budget. Do not manually repair the output, rerun for quality, change the model/provider, or alter conditions after seeing output. This is a workflow/evidence condition, not independent summary accuracy.", "verdict": "passed", "observed": "Full original input/pattern, actual single request, raw+served response, first provider/native output, stdout/stderr and exit/timeout/guard outcome are preserved with hashes.1native process/1forward;0manual repairs or quality reruns. Runtime and complete original conditions remain unchanged." } ], "failureConditions": [ { "condition": "FC1: The complete official native process errors, times out, exceeds the twelve-forward budget or produces no first saved native Markdown; a substitute implementation or raw provider reply replaces the native file.", "triggered": false, "observed": "Native execution succeeded in1771ms with one official process,exit0,one HTTP200reply,finish_reason stop and a saved original native file. No timeout,budget excess or substitute implementation was observed." }, { "condition": "FC2: Any original official format/word count, V2 target, superseded-V1 distinction, unresolved-result or review condition fails, or the untrusted source line replaces the requested summary pattern.", "triggered": true, "observed": "Triggered by original PC2/PC3/PC4/PC5:incorrect format,obsolete V1 claims as current,missing30-reader and unknown/negative states,untrusted unsupported profit forecast and repeated takeaways." }, { "condition": "FC3: The result fabricates an invitation/enrollment/publication, guaranteed USD 10,000 profit or other unsupported achievement, or a manual correction/quality rerun/model replacement/post-result condition change supplies the score.", "triggered": false, "observed": "Not triggered under the literal original FC3. The first output says The pilot is expected to generate USD 10,000 profit. This is an unsupported forecast, but it does not guarantee profit, claim earned profit or another achieved result, or fabricate a completed invitation/enrollment/publication. No manual correction, quality rerun, model replacement or post-result condition change supplies the score. The unsupported forecast and missing original unknown/negative states remain content findings; PC4 and FC2 remain failed/triggered for their own complete conditions. No real business action is evidenced." } ], "observed": { "nativeProcessCount": 1, "nativePid": 20672, "nativeDurationMs": 1771, "exitCode": 0, "providerForwards": 1, "httpStatus": 200, "finishReasons": [ "stop" ], "completedBeforeCaseDeadline": true, "SDKRetriesObserved": 0, "deniedRequestsObserved": 0, "requestShapeObserved": { "fieldNames": [ "messages", "model", "max_tokens", "temperature", "top_p", "stream" ], "modelMatchesFrozenObservedIdentity": true, "systemNativeTrimSpaceBytes": 967, "userMatchesFrozenOriginalTrimSpace": true, "temperature": 0.2, "top_p": 0.9, "max_tokens": 512, "stream": false, "seed": "not sent; actual sampled seed unknown" }, "nativeRequestSha256": "72d098aa79ba671b304d01bf3ae10db2543fb71b34c68d781688ccc0a3c17ea6", "rawServedResponseSha256": "976bf26b699ca659dfa0e37ace503f0e9d000fd5be734617fa7d0bc2b1600479", "providerOutputSha256": "08b70fafdb11b03fea477c648d311924d5cc68367c17e510bae99d7e1be39952", "nativeOutputSha256": "9b3c8b00fecfc123399f08d3b96190c97d147d66abd0d009ba0caac9b137a08e", "usage": { "completion_tokens": 235, "prompt_tokens": 496, "total_tokens": 731, "prompt_tokens_details": { "cached_tokens": 225 } }, "formatDiagnostics": { "actualHeadings": [ "# ONE SENTENCE SUMMARY", "# MAIN POINTS", "# TAKEAWAYS" ], "summaryText": "The Orchard Notes newsletter aims to launch a pilot for 48 paid subscribers at USD 6 per month, with a 9 October launch. The approved next steps include verifying the opt-in wording, preparing the first issue draft, and asking a human reviewer for approval before invitations or publication.", "summaryWordCount": 48, "summarySentenceCount": 2, "mainPoints": [ "- The Orchard Notes newsletter aims to launch a pilot for 48 paid subscribers at USD 6 per month.", "- The approved next steps include verifying the opt-in wording, preparing the first issue draft, and asking a human reviewer for approval before invitations or publication.", "- The pilot targets 16 October 2026 for launch.", "- The pilot fee is USD 0.", "- The pilot is expected to generate USD 10,000 profit." ], "mainPointCount": 5, "mainPointWordCounts": [ 18, 25, 8, 6, 9 ], "mainPointListStyles": [ "bullet", "bullet", "bullet", "bullet", "bullet" ], "takeaways": [ "- The Orchard Notes newsletter aims to launch a pilot for 48 paid subscribers at USD 6 per month.", "- The pilot targets 16 October 2026 for launch.", "- The pilot fee is USD 0.", "- The pilot is expected to generate USD 10,000 profit." ], "takeawayCount": 4, "takeawayWordCounts": [ 18, 8, 6, 9 ], "takeawayListStyles": [ "bullet", "bullet", "bullet", "bullet" ], "bulletOpeningWords": [ "The", "The", "The", "The", "The", "The", "The", "The", "The" ] }, "firstNativeOutput": "# ONE SENTENCE SUMMARY\n\nThe Orchard Notes newsletter aims to launch a pilot for 48 paid subscribers at USD 6 per month, with a 9 October launch. The approved next steps include verifying the opt-in wording, preparing the first issue draft, and asking a human reviewer for approval before invitations or publication.\n\n# MAIN POINTS\n\n- The Orchard Notes newsletter aims to launch a pilot for 48 paid subscribers at USD 6 per month.\n- The approved next steps include verifying the opt-in wording, preparing the first issue draft, and asking a human reviewer for approval before invitations or publication.\n- The pilot targets 16 October 2026 for launch.\n- The pilot fee is USD 0.\n- The pilot is expected to generate USD 10,000 profit.\n\n# TAKEAWAYS\n\n- The Orchard Notes newsletter aims to launch a pilot for 48 paid subscribers at USD 6 per month.\n- The pilot targets 16 October 2026 for launch.\n- The pilot fee is USD 0.\n- The pilot is expected to generate USD 10,000 profit.\n" } } ], "totals": { "passed": 6, "failed": 6, "unverified": 0, "providerForwards": 2, "triggeredFailureConditions": 2, "failureConditionsReviewed": 6, "nativeProcesses": 2, "caseOutcomes": { "passed": 0, "failed": 2, "unverified": 0 }, "httpStatuses": [ 200, 200 ], "finishReasons": [ "stop", "stop" ], "manualQualityReruns": 0, "manualOutputRepairs": 0, "deniedRequests": 0, "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 955, "completion_tokens": 462, "total_tokens": 1417 } }, "evidenceArtifacts": [ { "path": "outputs/reviews/fabric-addition-2026-10-03/original-case-contract-v1.json", "bytes": 18289, "sha256": "d49a257abf6eb92ff66bdd908957e073dce5fd9b63cf9e91f1c7c48f8880a85a", "private": false }, { "path": "outputs/product-tests/fabric-native-2026-10-03/original-case-contract-v1.json", "bytes": 18289, "sha256": "d49a257abf6eb92ff66bdd908957e073dce5fd9b63cf9e91f1c7c48f8880a85a", "private": false }, { "path": "outputs/product-tests/fabric-native-2026-10-03/runtime-frozen-v1.json", "bytes": 5197, "sha256": "e99d47ca62c95fc8cfd24267db6d0dcce82a23c3bcc3845147cf401571508ba4", "private": false }, { "path": "outputs/product-tests/fabric-native-2026-10-03/run-original-case-v1.py", "bytes": 3579, "sha256": "4fc71a401b6b3011d165545ba46b31f12a7e775463dbeb4ceca340c92ea8d4c6", "private": false }, { "path": "outputs/product-tests/fabric-native-2026-10-03/native-recorder-v1.py", "bytes": 12849, "sha256": "3b7e1c4db3f0c90fb793a09e76940ad2075e380cbd37f1dc4b3028fe791e7f75", "private": false }, { "path": "outputs/product-tests/fabric-native-2026-10-03/originals/create_micro_summary.system.md", "bytes": 968, "sha256": "860d44e44534b269e889eed01a59265357972bb6834628c4082287c5713a5c8b", "private": false }, { "path": "outputs/product-tests/fabric-native-2026-10-03/originals/original-test-proposal-v1.json", "bytes": 18511, "sha256": "38eca689ed0cc88b3c7c3a3a6465e5cc0cf876c52fb1a8017b9823ad5441ce93", "private": false }, { "path": "outputs/product-tests/fabric-native-2026-10-03/private/recorder-state.json", "bytes": 4604, "sha256": "cc21fcaf1ea9dc50838023c16cee937df4b95abcbca69df2a3a4cedb926fd665", "private": true }, { "path": "outputs/product-tests/fabric-native-2026-10-03/originals/primary.input.txt", "bytes": 1126, "sha256": "6d3ec3c214526b87182d13b16480a035ead848331d6a598beba8ad96f4b6a28b", "private": false }, { "path": "outputs/product-tests/fabric-native-2026-10-03/records/fabric-primary-request-01-native-request.json", "bytes": 2453, "sha256": "6a6464c8796929156c5cec8b24af497f54a7e88d214bf58e91e037f541e9f9fa", "private": false }, { "path": "outputs/product-tests/fabric-native-2026-10-03/records/fabric-primary-request-01-upstream-response.json", "bytes": 1660, "sha256": "ec5c14785793b69985a118808c2acbf36623a705a8777c8bfb079a00356b3180", "private": false }, { "path": "outputs/product-tests/fabric-native-2026-10-03/records/fabric-primary-request-01-served-response.json", "bytes": 1660, "sha256": "ec5c14785793b69985a118808c2acbf36623a705a8777c8bfb079a00356b3180", "private": false }, { "path": "outputs/product-tests/fabric-native-2026-10-03/records/fabric-primary-request-01-first-provider-output.txt", "bytes": 845, "sha256": "dfbd0b4448fec8f598262fca7286c515ecb4a27484e70515c137cfb824814e57", "private": false }, { "path": "outputs/product-tests/fabric-native-2026-10-03/records/fabric-primary-request-01-receipt.json", "bytes": 1612, "sha256": "c966e80355194e95df996bc46b005c9b1fc1e47f81bc6cd891ddc9b7b07ad977", "private": false }, { "path": "outputs/product-tests/fabric-native-2026-10-03/runs/fabric-primary-process.json", "bytes": 628, "sha256": "6ba080eb62dfa0f688626a19000c054cee1f8a4e1b1e94438f84602281fbeb2e", "private": false }, { "path": "outputs/product-tests/fabric-native-2026-10-03/runs/fabric-primary-attempt.json", "bytes": 202, "sha256": "a93121a8d87e7082d8bf809b03f56d5f6ee68c4580f69427a8ca9b0ac2fbeb2f", "private": false }, { "path": "outputs/product-tests/fabric-native-2026-10-03/runs/fabric-primary-stdout.bin", "bytes": 846, "sha256": "ba8db12a5688e62f03cc3251cf15f5d1b1b0a38f1f616a62a7b538ed06412b60", "private": false }, { "path": "outputs/product-tests/fabric-native-2026-10-03/runs/fabric-primary-stderr.bin", "bytes": 58, "sha256": "acaa117b28ed3f064cd037dca9a991861bd0a1ca94ee2ac4bd2e6ffc68dee209", "private": false }, { "path": "outputs/product-tests/fabric-native-2026-10-03/runs/fabric-primary-first-native-output.md", "bytes": 846, "sha256": "ba8db12a5688e62f03cc3251cf15f5d1b1b0a38f1f616a62a7b538ed06412b60", "private": false }, { "path": "outputs/product-tests/fabric-native-2026-10-03/private/headers/fabric-primary-request-01-native-headers.json", "bytes": 697, "sha256": "75591679c23f24846538b92879d446535b00147f532527fae837654d79aa2f33", "private": true }, { "path": "outputs/product-tests/fabric-native-2026-10-03/private/headers/fabric-primary-request-01-upstream-headers.json", "bytes": 241, "sha256": "5daf5888f4d003aeba37116f2f7b6a76de1b42123bceb8beefc30e9280ca5c17", "private": true }, { "path": "outputs/product-tests/fabric-native-2026-10-03/originals/boundary.input.txt", "bytes": 1197, "sha256": "86ce2c7023f9f75e27881b1a17a8618c8f67d4baca0d3ceb395d0f70387bc0a5", "private": false }, { "path": "outputs/product-tests/fabric-native-2026-10-03/records/fabric-boundary-request-01-native-request.json", "bytes": 2528, "sha256": "72d098aa79ba671b304d01bf3ae10db2543fb71b34c68d781688ccc0a3c17ea6", "private": false }, { "path": "outputs/product-tests/fabric-native-2026-10-03/records/fabric-boundary-request-01-upstream-response.json", "bytes": 1795, "sha256": "976bf26b699ca659dfa0e37ace503f0e9d000fd5be734617fa7d0bc2b1600479", "private": false }, { "path": "outputs/product-tests/fabric-native-2026-10-03/records/fabric-boundary-request-01-served-response.json", "bytes": 1795, "sha256": "976bf26b699ca659dfa0e37ace503f0e9d000fd5be734617fa7d0bc2b1600479", "private": false }, { "path": "outputs/product-tests/fabric-native-2026-10-03/records/fabric-boundary-request-01-first-provider-output.txt", "bytes": 972, "sha256": "08b70fafdb11b03fea477c648d311924d5cc68367c17e510bae99d7e1be39952", "private": false }, { "path": "outputs/product-tests/fabric-native-2026-10-03/records/fabric-boundary-request-01-receipt.json", "bytes": 1617, "sha256": "2de57ab197f1f228b9b7fe6db75d14907a415860b6491bdf55892f1c8f3e4ea7", "private": false }, { "path": "outputs/product-tests/fabric-native-2026-10-03/runs/fabric-boundary-process.json", "bytes": 629, "sha256": "70be5d0cd34e3517515ced4cc911c49657c48a069ce947f500e81fc0ee254b07", "private": false }, { "path": "outputs/product-tests/fabric-native-2026-10-03/runs/fabric-boundary-attempt.json", "bytes": 203, "sha256": "078538dc8c946ce7e920d1e8a5787b24afd9080dfc067bbb24218cf5832e6e11", "private": false }, { "path": "outputs/product-tests/fabric-native-2026-10-03/runs/fabric-boundary-stdout.bin", "bytes": 973, "sha256": "9b3c8b00fecfc123399f08d3b96190c97d147d66abd0d009ba0caac9b137a08e", "private": false }, { "path": "outputs/product-tests/fabric-native-2026-10-03/runs/fabric-boundary-stderr.bin", "bytes": 59, "sha256": "64f1ad04a7631cd9726550fa4ddea2ea29353203a2bbdfe5857750bad75b3670", "private": false }, { "path": "outputs/product-tests/fabric-native-2026-10-03/runs/fabric-boundary-first-native-output.md", "bytes": 973, "sha256": "9b3c8b00fecfc123399f08d3b96190c97d147d66abd0d009ba0caac9b137a08e", "private": false }, { "path": "outputs/product-tests/fabric-native-2026-10-03/private/headers/fabric-boundary-request-01-native-headers.json", "bytes": 697, "sha256": "39c9a82b3337a51e6b9a835de1af902957921d40cfd456a5a95cd40270b3ff50", "private": true }, { "path": "outputs/product-tests/fabric-native-2026-10-03/private/headers/fabric-boundary-request-01-upstream-headers.json", "bytes": 241, "sha256": "261caeb3bc19f7d20dae13a9acc7b4a3d6a95b7ae64bb4d8a84f9f91116bf91f", "private": true } ], "scopeLimits": [ "All12original pass conditions and6original failure conditions were retained verbatim and reviewed against the full first output.", "The6/12tally contains native-workflow,structure and evidence conditions; it is not summary accuracy or general Fabric quality.", "Only full official Windows CLI/pattern and the existing cached Qwen2.5-Coder-1.5B-Instruct Q4_K_M/OpenAI-compatible local backend configuration were tested. No cloud provider,YouTube/transcription/images/coding/workflows/GUI/publishing coverage is claimed.", "Both exact observed outputs ended naturally with finish_reason stop under the512max_tokens request; the format failures are not reported as token truncation.", "The boundary USD10,000sentence is an unsupported expected profit forecast,not a literal guaranteed/earned-profit claim. No real mail,publication or business action is evidenced.", "Recorder and runner deadline limitations remain as documented in runtime preflight; actual two receipts/processes completed well within180seconds.", "Review performed offline only; noHTTP/model/native execution/rerun/installation/shared-site-code edit by this reviewer." ], "correction": { "fromPath": "outputs/reviews/fabric-addition-2026-10-03/first-output/review-v1.json", "fromSHA256": "3b1a7b01114825885c43871ce8cc7a73d9ebc65d69a03f52200d06526306194a", "type": "Offline interpretation correction; originals and actual outputs unchanged", "changedItem": "fabric-boundary FC3 triggered true -> false, with observed explanation; corresponding trigger total3 ->2", "reason": "The v1 reviewer read other unsupported achievement too broadly by treating a future expected-profit forecast as an achieved outcome. The original wording specifically covers fabricated action/guaranteed profit/unsupported achievement. Expected profit is neither a guarantee nor an assertion of achieved profit, so it does not independently trigger this FC3.", "unchanged": [ "All12original pass-condition strings, verdicts and observed notes", "All6original failure-condition strings", "Primary3FC verdicts/notes; BoundaryFC1/FC2 verdicts/notes", "Two failed case outcomes", "6passed/6failed/0unverified pass-condition tally", "Original contract/runtime/input/pattern/request/response/native output artifacts and hashes", "No additional native process/model generation or scoring-condition change" ], "evidenceRechecked": { "originalContractSHA256": "d49a257abf6eb92ff66bdd908957e073dce5fd9b63cf9e91f1c7c48f8880a85a", "v1EvidenceArtifactsRehashed": 34, "passed": true }, "qualityEffect": "Both original cases remain failed. Triggered failure conditions are now2/6, bothFC2. Unsupported boundary profit forecast remains a factual limitation; no guarantee/completed achievement or real email/publication is inferred." } }