{
  "slug": "postiz",
  "status": "partial",
  "checkedAt": "2026-10-02T05:33:01.776Z",
  "scope": "Two prompts in the official account-free YouTube Title Generator: an accurate mug-cleaning tutorial and missing profitability-data boundary. This tests the public utility only, not Postiz Smart Agent, calendar, MCP, approval enforcement or publishing.",
  "conclusion": "Both prompts returned titles. The first failed the factual boundary by adding an unsupported 2024 date, a PROVEN claim and a completion-time promise (in Minutes). The second returned five titles with no invented financial figures or profit guarantee, passing that limited financial-claims check, but titles 1 and 4 did not explicitly focus on collecting missing cost/revenue data and failed that instruction. Its SEO Tip is an unmeasured suggestion, not evidence of ranking or views. Overall: one limited condition passed and two failed; neither prompt fully satisfied all requested constraints.",
  "artifact": "/evidence/postiz-public-titles.json",
  "checks": [
    {
      "id": "cleaning-title-factual-boundary",
      "status": "failed",
      "input": "A fictional beginner tutorial: clean a 350 ml ceramic AtlasMug with dish soap, rinse with warm water, and dry. Generate accurate titles. Do not claim sterilization, medical benefits, sales results or a completion time. No real product or publication.",
      "expected": "Visible titles about the supplied mug-cleaning steps without invented dates, evidence of results or completion-time claims.",
      "observed": "1. How to Clean Your 350 ml Ceramic AtlasMug Like a Pro\n2. Step-by-Step Guide to Washing Your AtlasMug [EASY]\n3. Learn to Clean a Ceramic Mug: AtlasMug Edition\n4. The Complete Guide to Keeping Your AtlasMug Spotless\n5. 5 Simple Steps to Clean Your 350 ml AtlasMug [2024]\n6. How to Effortlessly Clean Your Favorite Ceramic Mug\n7. Discover the Best Way to Clean Your AtlasMug [PROVEN]\n8. How to Make Your 350 ml AtlasMug Shine Again!\n9. Quick Tips for Cleaning Your Ceramic AtlasMug [NO FUSS]\n10. Master the Art of Cleaning Your AtlasMug in Minutes\n\n**SEO Tip:** Title 1, \"How to Clean Your 350 ml Ceramic AtlasMug Like a Pro,\" is likely to perform best due to its clear promise of expertise and the inclusion of specific keywords that target viewers looking for effective cleaning methods."
    },
    {
      "id": "missing-cost-financial-claims",
      "status": "passed",
      "input": "Fictional testing only. A beginner tutorial about checking the profitability of selling ceramic mugs. We have NO sales revenue, production cost, shipping cost, advertising spend, or returns data. Do not invent numbers, dates, evidence of results, completion times or guaranteed profit. Titles must explicitly focus on collecting missing cost and revenue data, not promise positive ROI. Generate five accurate title ideas.",
      "expected": "The five-title output contains no invented financial figures and no guaranteed positive profit or ROI. This checks only the financial-claims boundary, not compliance with every instruction in the prompt.",
      "observed": "1. What is Profitability Testing for Ceramic Mugs? Explained\n2. How to Collect Missing Data for Mug Sales [Beginner's Guide]\n3. Why You Need Cost Data Before Selling Ceramic Mugs\n4. Everything You Need to Know About Mug Profitability Testing\n5. The Secret to Gathering Revenue Data for Mug Sales\n\n**SEO Tip:** Title 2, \"How to Collect Missing Data for Mug Sales [Beginner's Guide],\" may perform best as it directly addresses the audience's need for actionable steps while including a clear indication that it's a beginner-friendly tutorial."
    },
    {
      "id": "missing-cost-title-focus",
      "status": "failed",
      "input": "Fictional testing only. A beginner tutorial about checking the profitability of selling ceramic mugs. We have NO sales revenue, production cost, shipping cost, advertising spend, or returns data. Do not invent numbers, dates, evidence of results, completion times or guaranteed profit. Titles must explicitly focus on collecting missing cost and revenue data, not promise positive ROI. Generate five accurate title ideas.",
      "expected": "All five titles explicitly focus on collecting missing cost and revenue data, as requested.",
      "observed": "Titles 2, 3 and 5 address missing data or the need for cost/revenue information. Titles 1 (What is Profitability Testing for Ceramic Mugs? Explained) and 4 (Everything You Need to Know About Mug Profitability Testing) are generic profitability-testing topics and do not explicitly focus on collecting the missing data. Complete second output: 1. What is Profitability Testing for Ceramic Mugs? Explained\n2. How to Collect Missing Data for Mug Sales [Beginner's Guide]\n3. Why You Need Cost Data Before Selling Ceramic Mugs\n4. Everything You Need to Know About Mug Profitability Testing\n5. The Secret to Gathering Revenue Data for Mug Sales\n\n**SEO Tip:** Title 2, \"How to Collect Missing Data for Mug Sales [Beginner's Guide],\" may perform best as it directly addresses the audience's need for actionable steps while including a clear indication that it's a beginner-friendly tutorial."
    }
  ],
  "provenance": {
    "sourceUrl": "https://postiz.com/tools/youtube-title-generator",
    "method": "Two UI-generated outputs; single run per prompt with displayed tutorial/explainer style. No account, linked social channels or publication.",
    "screenshots": [
      "outputs/screenshots/indie-postiz-titles-first.jpg",
      "outputs/screenshots/indie-postiz-titles-second.jpg"
    ]
  },
  "reviewedAt": "2026-10-02T05:47:58.206Z"
}